Your membership has expired, click here to renew!

Our Views

Our Views Columns

Date: 5/17/2018

Title: Keep the Beef Checkoff in the Hands of Producers

By Kevin Kester, 2018 NCBA President

Every beef producer knows that demand is king. Investing the time, resources, and hard labor required to raise cattle and produce beef only makes sense if consumers are willing to buy the final product. That is why in 1988, the nation’s cattle and beef producers voted to approve a consumer marketing program known as the Beef Checkoff. Today, despite having support from three of four producers, that program is under attack.

The misguided effort to unwind years of producer-led work comes from U.S. Representatives Dave Brat (R-VA) and Earl Blumenauer (D-OR). Together Representatives Brat and Blumenauer are pushing an amendment to the 2018 Farm Bill that would harm the beef industry and undermine producer control of the Beef Checkoff Program.

Producer control has been a defining feature of the Beef Checkoff since its inception. Established by an act of Congress in 1985, the Beef Checkoff was only made official following a successful producer referendum in 1988. Nearly 80 percent of producers voted to authorize the collection of a mandatory $1-per-head fee on any sale of cattle in the U.S.

The funds collected from producers are used for research and promotion programs designed to benefit the entire industry. A committee of 20 elected industry leaders develop the budget and program plans. From nutritional studies and food safety research, to retail partnerships and foreign marketing, the Beef Checkoff funds critical work that builds consumer demand for beef. 

It is a sad day when Congress attempts to wrest control of an industry self-help program away from those who manage and pay for it. But by removing the ability of the Beef Checkoff to contract with any organization that engages in agricultural advocacy, the Brat-Blumenauer amendment would do precisely that. Producers fund the Beef Checkoff out of their own pockets, with no cost to the taxpayer. They should have the right to determine which organizations they can and cannot do business with.

Thus far producers have proven perfectly capable of deciding how to spend their money. Beef producers fund roughly $72 million of research, promotion and consumer education programs each year. Independent research shows these programs result in an $11.20 return on investment for every dollar invested.

 

Evidently Representatives Brat and Blumenauer are willing to ignore the Beef Checkoff’s substantial record of success. They claim the amendment will improve transparency and accountability for all commodity checkoff programs, including beef. However, their amendment looks like a classic case of a government solution in search of a problem.  

Existing law already requires the USDA to provide oversight to ensure checkoff programs are managed responsibly and efficiently. It also requires fair treatment of all stakeholders and a strict prohibition on using any checkoff dollars to fund lobbying activities. In fact, checkoff programs are subjected to annual audits to insure all expenses are used only for projects and other expenses authorized in a budget approved by USDA. USDA also conducts a review of checkoff management practices and internal controls at least once every three years.

Producers expect attacks on checkoff programs from opponents of animal agriculture. Groups like the Humane Society of the United States have tried to dismantle checkoff programs for years. They hate that producers have found an effective way to pool their resources and grow demand for their products. It is regrettable that some members of Congress have chosen to follow in their footsteps.

If producers were unhappy with the results of the Beef Checkoff, they could end it. A new referendum on the program can be held at any time following a request from at least 10% of producers. The critical point is that the decision would be theirs and theirs alone. Dictating Beef Checkoff operations is not the role of Congress. True friends of beef producers should vigorously oppose the Brat-Blumenauer amendment.